What Happens If The Insurer Refuses To Tender Policy Limits

Name

Email*

Phone*

Message*

Get My Free Case Review

Confidential Case Review • No Fee Unless We Win

This scenario, unfortunately, is all too common. Insurance companies are businesses, and their goal is to minimize payouts. When they refuse to tender their full policy limits—that is, offer the maximum amount available under the policy—it’s often a calculated risk. They’re betting you won’t sue, or that a jury will award less than what it would cost them to settle. But it’s a risky gamble for them, and one that can expose them to significant liability.

The reality is, an insurance company’s refusal to settle a legitimate claim within policy limits can create a legal basis for a “bad faith” lawsuit. California law implies a duty of good faith and fair dealing in every insurance contract. This means they must investigate claims thoroughly, make reasonable settlement offers, and act in the best interests of their insured – which, surprisingly, extends to protecting the rights of you, the injured party, from unnecessary litigation.

I’ve spent over 13 years representing clients in San Diego, and I’ve seen firsthand how insurance companies operate. I was even trained by former defense attorneys, giving me intimate knowledge of their evaluation tactics. They often undervalue claims, delay responses, and employ strategies designed to wear you down. Knowing their playbook is a significant advantage when negotiating a fair settlement.

What is “Bad Faith” and How Does it Apply to Insurance Claims?

“Bad faith” isn’t simply about being rude or difficult. It’s a legal term with a specific meaning. In California, an insurer acts in bad faith when it unreasonably denies, fails to investigate, or undervalues a claim without a reasonable basis. This can include ignoring medical evidence, relying on biased evaluations, or misrepresenting policy language. A refusal to settle within policy limits, when liability is clear, is a key indicator of potential bad faith.

To successfully pursue a bad faith claim, you must demonstrate that the insurer acted unreasonably in denying or underpaying your claim. This requires careful documentation of all communication, medical records, and evidence supporting your damages. It also requires understanding the legal standards that define “reasonable” conduct in the context of insurance claims.

Proving bad faith is complex, and it’s not a claim you want to handle on your own. It requires a deep understanding of insurance law and the tactics insurance companies employ. Without proper legal representation, you risk losing valuable rights and settling for far less than you deserve.

What Damages Can I Recover in a Bad Faith Lawsuit?

If you can successfully prove bad faith, you may be entitled to more than just the original policy limits. Bad faith damages can include the full amount of your compensatory damages – medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering – plus punitive damages intended to punish the insurer for their misconduct. Punitive damages can be substantial, particularly in cases involving gross negligence or intentional wrongdoing.

Furthermore, you may be able to recover attorney’s fees and costs associated with the bad faith litigation. This can significantly reduce your out-of-pocket expenses and make it financially viable to pursue a claim you otherwise might not have considered. The goal is to make the insurer whole, and to deter similar misconduct in the future.

Remember, insurance companies often have internal guidelines dictating settlement practices. They’re not making decisions based on fairness alone; they’re making decisions based on profit. A skilled attorney can uncover those guidelines and use them to your advantage.

What Evidence Do I Need to Support a Bad Faith Claim?

Gathering evidence is crucial. Keep meticulous records of all communication with the insurance company, including dates, times, and the names of anyone you speak with. Preserve all medical records, bills, and documentation of lost wages. Obtain police reports and any witness statements related to the accident. Any dashcam footage or digital evidence is invaluable.

Furthermore, document any attempts you’ve made to negotiate with the insurer. If they ignore your requests or provide inadequate responses, keep a record of it. Any internal communications from the insurer, such as claim notes or evaluation reports, can also be powerful evidence. In San Diego, we frequently utilize the discovery process to obtain this information from the insurance company.

Finally, it’s important to understand that the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate bad faith. That’s why it’s so important to work with an attorney who has experience handling these types of cases and knows how to build a strong evidentiary record.

Can I File a Bad Faith Claim Against the Insured Driver Personally?

Generally, no. Bad faith claims are typically brought against the insurance company, not the at-fault driver. The driver is protected by the insurance policy, and the insurer is responsible for handling the claim in good faith. However, there may be rare exceptions to this rule, such as cases where the driver intentionally misrepresented facts to the insurer.

It’s important to focus your efforts on the insurance company, as they have the financial resources to pay your claim. Pursuing a claim against the driver personally is often unproductive and may not yield significant results. Your attorney can advise you on the best course of action based on the specific circumstances of your case.

Understanding these complexities is vital. Filing a lawsuit against an insurance company is a serious matter, and you need an advocate who can protect your rights and fight for the compensation you deserve.

What Should I Do If I Believe My Insurer is Acting in Bad Faith?

If you suspect your insurer is acting in bad faith, don’t delay. Contact an experienced attorney immediately. They can review your claim, assess the potential for a bad faith lawsuit, and advise you on the best course of action. Don’t continue negotiating with the insurance company without legal representation, as any statements you make could be used against you.

The sooner you seek legal assistance, the better. There are statutes of limitations governing bad faith claims, and you risk losing your right to sue if you wait too long. Protecting your rights requires prompt action and a thorough understanding of your legal options.

An initial consultation with an attorney is typically free, and it can provide valuable insight into your case. It’s a small investment that can potentially save you tens of thousands of dollars in the long run.