Morse Injury Law helping San Diego motorcycle victims while explaining: What If The Defense Hires Private Investigators?

What If The Defense Hires Private Investigators?

Alvaro was enjoying a rare weekend ride through the Palomar Mountains when a distracted driver blew through a stop sign, colliding with him at 45 mph. The impact shattered his femur, requiring multiple surgeries and leaving him facing over $123,892 in medical bills—and that didn’t even include lost income from his job as a software engineer.

Confidential Confidential Case Review • No Fee Unless We Win

Attorney Richard Morse a San Diego Injury Attorney

One of the first things I’ve learned in 13+ years of practicing personal injury law in San Diego is that insurance companies rarely take claims at face value. They’re in the business of minimizing payouts, and a common tactic they employ is hiring private investigators (PIs) to scrutinize the claimant’s life. This can feel invasive and unsettling, but understanding their methods and your rights is crucial to protecting your claim.

I was trained by a former insurance defense attorney, giving me intimate knowledge of how insurance companies evaluate, devalue, and deny claims. They don’t want you to know what they’re looking for, but I do. They’ll often focus on discrediting your injury claims, finding inconsistencies in your statements, or attempting to portray you as someone with a questionable character. Knowing this allows us to proactively address potential issues and build a stronger case.

What are insurance companies hoping to find with a private investigator?

Morse Injury Law helping San Diego motorcycle victims while explaining: What If The Defense Hires Private Investigators?

Insurance companies hire PIs for a variety of reasons, all aimed at reducing their financial liability. They’re not necessarily looking for criminal activity, but rather anything that could undermine your credibility or the severity of your injuries. Common areas of investigation include surveillance to document your daily activities, background checks to uncover prior claims or inconsistencies in your history, and social media monitoring to find potentially damaging information.

Specifically, they’ll often look for video or photographic evidence contradicting your reported limitations. For example, if you claim you can’t lift more than 10 pounds, they might try to capture footage of you lifting heavy objects. They may also investigate your employment history, looking for discrepancies between your claimed lost wages and your actual earnings. Social media posts showing you engaging in activities you claim you can’t do are another common target.

It’s important to remember that insurance companies are allowed to investigate claims, but they are not allowed to engage in illegal or unethical behavior. This includes harassment, trespassing, or misrepresentation. If you suspect that a PI is violating your rights, it’s crucial to consult with an attorney immediately.

How can I protect myself if I know a private investigator is following me?

If you suspect you’re under surveillance, the best course of action is to maintain your normal routine as much as possible. Avoid making drastic changes to your activities simply because you think you’re being watched. Continue attending medical appointments, following your doctor’s orders, and engaging in the activities you’ve described to your insurance adjuster.

Document everything. Keep a detailed log of your daily activities, including the dates, times, and locations of your appointments, errands, and social engagements. If you see a suspicious vehicle or individual, note their description and license plate number. Be mindful of your surroundings and avoid engaging with the investigator directly. Do not confront them, and do not admit to anything you wouldn’t want them to report to the insurance company.

Finally, be cautious about what you post on social media. Even seemingly harmless posts can be taken out of context and used against you. Consider adjusting your privacy settings to limit who can see your content, or temporarily deactivating your accounts altogether.

What should I do if a private investigator contacts me directly?

You are under no obligation to speak with a private investigator hired by the insurance company. In fact, it’s generally best to avoid any direct communication with them. Politely decline to answer any questions and immediately consult with your attorney. Any statements you make to a PI can be used against you, even if you believe you’re being cooperative.

If the investigator persists in contacting you, inform them that you are represented by counsel and direct all future communication to your attorney. Do not engage in any further conversation with them, and document the date and time of each contact attempt. They are legally obligated to respect your right to legal representation.

Remember, insurance companies are skilled at manipulating information and twisting facts to their advantage. Having an experienced attorney on your side can level the playing field and protect your rights throughout the claims process. In San Diego, I’ve seen countless cases where a proactive approach to dealing with PIs has made all the difference in securing a fair settlement for my clients.

What if the investigator is harassing me or trespassing on my property?

Harassment and trespassing are illegal, and you have the right to protect yourself from such behavior. If a private investigator is engaging in these tactics, document everything, including the dates, times, and locations of each incident. Take photos or videos if possible, and report the incidents to the police.

Your attorney can then take legal action to stop the harassment and seek damages for any harm you’ve suffered. This may include a restraining order or a lawsuit against the investigator and the insurance company. It’s important to remember that you are not required to tolerate illegal or unethical behavior from anyone, including a private investigator.

Can I sue the insurance company for hiring a private investigator?

While it’s not always possible to sue the insurance company simply for hiring a private investigator, you may have grounds for a lawsuit if the investigator engaged in illegal or unethical behavior, such as harassment, trespassing, or misrepresentation. These actions can constitute invasion of privacy, defamation, or intentional infliction of emotional distress.

To successfully sue the insurance company, you’ll need to prove that the investigator’s actions were intentional, malicious, and caused you actual harm. This may require gathering evidence such as witness testimony, photos, and videos. Your attorney can assess your specific situation and advise you on the best course of action.

What is the role of recorded statements in relation to private investigators?

Insurance companies often request recorded statements from claimants early in the claims process. While seemingly innocuous, these statements can be used to identify inconsistencies and create grounds for denying your claim. Private investigators often review these recordings to pinpoint areas of vulnerability.

It is almost always best to avoid giving a recorded statement without first consulting with an attorney. We can prepare you for the questions you’re likely to be asked and ensure that your responses are accurate and consistent. We can also advise you on whether to decline the request altogether, especially if you suspect you’re being investigated.

How long do I have to file a claim if I’ve been injured in a motorcycle accident?

In California, you have a **two-year** window from the date of the motorcycle accident to file a lawsuit for personal injury. Because evidence at a crash scene—such as skid marks or GoPro footage—can disappear quickly, immediate filing is critical to preserve the integrity of the claim. CCP § 335.1

What if my accident involved a government vehicle or roadway hazard?

If a motorcycle accident involves a government-owned vehicle or a dangerous road condition like loose gravel, potholes, or poorly marked construction zones, a formal administrative claim **MUST** be presented within **6 months** (180 days). Failure to meet this strict deadline under the Government Tort Claims Act can result in the permanent loss of your right to recover. Gov. Code § 911.2

Is lane splitting legal in California, and how does it affect my claim?

California law formally recognizes lane splitting as legal, defined as driving a motorcycle between rows of stopped or moving vehicles in the same lane. In accident litigation, proving that the maneuver was performed ‘in a safe and prudent manner’ is essential to rebutting claims of rider negligence. CVC § 21658.1

What if I wasn’t wearing a helmet at the time of the accident?

California is a universal helmet law state, requiring all riders and passengers to wear a safety helmet that meets DOT standards. While a violation may be used by defense counsel to argue for a reduction in damages via comparative fault—specifically regarding head or neck injuries—it does not bar a rider from seeking recovery for other injuries caused by a negligent driver. CVC § 27803

How does California’s comparative fault system apply to motorcycle accidents?

California’s ‘pure’ comparative fault system applies to motorcycle claims. Even if a driver argues you shared responsibility due to speed or positioning, you can still recover damages; however, your total compensation will be reduced by your percentage of fault. Civ. Code § 1714

Authority Reference Grid: San Diego Motorcycle Accidents
CCP § 335.1
2-year injury filing deadline.
Gov § 911.2
6-month public entity claim limit.
Civ § 1714
Pure comparative negligence.
Civ § 3294
Punitive damages authority.
CVC § 21801
Left-turn right-of-way rule.
CVC § 22107
Unsafe lane change violations.
CVC § 22350
Basic speed law.
CVC § 23152
DUI causing injury.
CVC § 20001
Injury hit-and-run.
CVC § 21658.1
Lane splitting legality.
CVC § 27803
Mandatory helmet law.
Gov § 835
Dangerous public property liability.
Ins § 11580.2
UM/UIM coverage rights.
Ins § 790.03
Unfair claim practices.
CCP § 377.60
Wrongful death standing.
CACI 1200
Strict product liability standard.

Similar Posts